43e législature, 1re session

 

43rd Parliament, 1st session


 

43e Législature, 1re session


 

Votes and Proceedings


 

Procès-verbaux


 

No. 111



 

Nº 111



 

Monday
November 20, 2023


 

Lundi
20 novembre 2023


 

Hon. Ted Arnott
Speaker

L'hon. Ted Arnott
le président

MONDAY, NOVEMBER 20, 2023
ONE HUNDRED AND ELEVENTH DAY

LUNDI 20 NOVEMBRE 2023
CENT ONZIÈME JOUR

10:15 A.M.

Prayers

10 H 15

Prières
  O Canada     Ô Canada     
 Royal Anthem     Hymne royale

The Speaker informed the House,

Le Président a informé l’Assemblée,

That, in accordance with Section 87 of the Legislative Assembly Act, the names of the following persons appointed to serve as alternates on the Board of Internal Economy have been communicated to me as Chair of the Board of Internal Economy:
The Honourable Andrea Khanjin, MPP, is appointed by the Lieutenant Governor in Council from among the members of the Executive Council; and
Terence Kernaghan, MPP, is appointed by the Caucus of the Official Opposition.

At 10:29 a.m., the House observed a moment of silence in honour of the Trans Day of Remembrance.

À 10 h 29, l’Assemblée a observé une minute de silence pour marquer la Journée du souvenir trans.

Deferred Votes

Votes différés

Motion for closure on the amendment to amendment to the motion regarding taxes on fuels for home heating.

Motion de clôture sur le sous-amendement à la motion concernant les taxes sur les combustibles à chauffage résidentiel.

Carried on the following division:

Adoptée par le vote suivant :

Ayes/pour (88)
Anand Armstrong Barnes Begum
Bethlenfalvy Bouma Bourgouin Brady
Bresee Byers Calandra Cho (Scarborough North)
Cho (Willowdale) Clark Coe Crawford
Cuzzetto Dixon Dowie Downey
Dunlop Fedeli Fife Flack
Ford (Etobicoke North) Ford (York South—Weston) French Gallagher Murphy
Gates Gélinas Ghamari Gill
Gretzky Grewal Hardeman Harris
Hogarth Holland Jones (Chatham-Kent—Leamington) Jordan
Kanapathi Ke Kernaghan Kerzner
Khanjin Kusendova-Bashta Leardi Lecce
Lumsden MacLeod Mamakwa Mantha
Martin McCarthy McGregor Mulroney
Pang Parsa Pasma Piccini
Pierre Pirie Quinn Rae
Rakocevic Rickford Riddell Sabawy
Sandhu Sarrazin Sattler Saunderson
Shaw Skelly Smith (Peterborough—Kawartha) Smith (Scarborough Centre)
Smith (Thornhill) Stevens Stiles Surma
Tangri Thompson Tibollo Triantafilopoulos
Vanthof Vaugeois Wai Williams
Nays/contre (8)
Blais Bowman Collard Fraser
Hazell McCrimmon Schreiner Shamji

The question was then put on the motion, as follows:

La question sur la motion a ensuite été mise aux voix, comme suite :

John Jordan moved,

John Jordan a proposé,

That, in the opinion of this House, the Government of Canada should take immediate steps to eliminate the carbon tax on fuels and inputs for home heating.

Carried on the following division:

Adoptée par le vote suivant :

Ayes/pour (89)
Anand Armstrong Barnes Begum
Bethlenfalvy Blais Bouma Bourgouin
Brady Bresee Byers Calandra
Cho (Scarborough North) Cho (Willowdale) Clark Coe
Crawford Cuzzetto Dixon Dowie
Downey Dunlop Fedeli Fife
Flack Ford (Etobicoke North) Ford (York South—Weston) French
Gallagher Murphy Gates Gélinas Ghamari
Gill Gretzky Grewal Hardeman
Harris Hogarth Holland Jones (Chatham-Kent—Leamington)
Jordan Kanapathi Ke Kernaghan
Kerzner Khanjin Kusendova-Bashta Leardi
Lecce Lumsden MacLeod Mamakwa
Mantha Martin McCarthy McGregor
Mulroney Pang Parsa Pasma
Piccini Pierre Pirie Quinn
Rae Rakocevic Rickford Riddell
Sabawy Sandhu Sarrazin Sattler
Saunderson Shaw Skelly Smith (Peterborough—Kawartha)
Smith (Scarborough Centre) Smith (Thornhill) Stevens Stiles
Surma Tangri Thompson Tibollo
Triantafilopoulos Vanthof Vaugeois Wai
Williams    
Nays/contre (7)
Bowman Collard Fraser Hazell
McCrimmon Schreiner Shamji  
Resolved, That, in the opinion of this House, the Government of Canada should take immediate steps to eliminate the carbon tax on fuels and inputs for home heating.

Second Reading of Bill 40, An Act to amend the Highway Traffic Act to provide for consequences to those who cause injury or death to certain road users.

Deuxième lecture du projet de loi 40, Loi modifiant le Code de la route pour prévoir les conséquences qu'encourent les personnes qui causent des blessures à certains usagers de la route ou leur décès.

Lost on the following division:

Rejetée par le vote suivant :

Ayes/pour (33)
Armstrong Begum Bell Blais
Bourgouin Bowman Brady Collard
Fife Fraser French Gates
Gélinas Glover Gretzky Harden
Hazell Karpoche Kernaghan Mamakwa
Mantha McCrimmon Pasma Rakocevic
Sattler Schreiner Shamji Shaw
Stevens Stiles Vanthof Vaugeois
Wong-Tam    
Nays/contre (67)
Anand Barnes Bethlenfalvy Bouma
Bresee Byers Calandra Cho (Scarborough North)
Cho (Willowdale) Clark Coe Crawford
Cuzzetto Dixon Dowie Downey
Dunlop Fedeli Ford (Etobicoke North) Ford (York South—Weston)
Gallagher Murphy Ghamari Gill Grewal
Hardeman Harris Hogarth Holland
Jones (Chatham-Kent—Leamington) Jordan Kanapathi Ke
Kerzner Khanjin Kusendova-Bashta Leardi
Lecce Lumsden MacLeod Martin
McCarthy McGregor Mulroney Pang
Parsa Piccini Pierre Pirie
Quinn Rae Rickford Riddell
Sabawy Sandhu Sarrazin Saunderson
Skelly Smith (Peterborough—Kawartha) Smith (Scarborough Centre) Smith (Thornhill)
Surma Tangri Thompson Tibollo
Triantafilopoulos Wai Williams  

The House recessed at 12:17 p.m.

À 12:17, l’Assemblée a suspendu la séance.


1:00 P.M.

13 H

Reports by Committees

Rapports de comités

The Speaker addressed the House as follows:

Standing Order 66(a) provides that each Standing Committee shall present one report with respect to all of the Estimates and Supplementary Estimates considered no later than the third Thursday in November of each calendar year.

The House did not receive a report on Thursday, November 16, 2023 from the following Committee:

 

Standing Committee on Heritage, Infrastructure and Cultural Policy for the Office of the Lieutenant Governor.

 

Accordingly, the 2023-2024 Estimates of the following Office was deemed to be passed by the Committee and were deemed to be reported to and received by the House:

 

OFFICE OF THE LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR

1701

Office of the Lieutenant Governor

$

2,831,400

 

Petitions

Pétitions

No./ Petition title/Titre de la pétition Presented by/Présentée par
P-21 Health care privatization Sandy Shaw
P-21 Health care privatization Jennifer (Jennie) Stevens
P-31 Replacement workers Jennifer K. French
P-132 Safety in bars and restaurants Peggy Sattler
P-136 University of Sudbury Guy Bourgouin
P-159 Classroom safety Terence Kernaghan
P-162 Registered Nurses Catherine Fife

Orders of the Day

Ordres du jour

Opposition Day

Jour de l'opposition

Marit Stiles moved,

Marit Stiles a proposé,

Whereas Ontarians are experiencing a cost-of-living crisis driven by low wages and corporate greed; and
Whereas costs associated with the climate crisis are also increasing, including grocery and insurance prices, infrastructure damage, and natural disaster response; and
Whereas the Ontario Government has made the climate crisis worse and more expensive by eliminating funding to make homes more energy efficient, cancelling clean energy projects, and removing protections from farmlands;
Therefore, the Legislative Assembly calls on the Ontario Government, in partnership with the federal government, to subsidize the cost of heat pumps and other energy-saving retrofits for all Ontarians, in order to cut greenhouse gas emissions and reduce energy bills.

Debate arose and after some time,

Il s’élève un débat et après quelque temps,

The question was then put.

La question a ensuite été mise aux voix.

Lost on the following division:

Rejetée par le vote suivant :

Ayes/pour (31)
Armstrong Begum Bell Blais
Bourgouin Bowman Brady Collard
Fife Fraser French Gates
Gélinas Gretzky Harden Hazell
Kernaghan Mamakwa Mantha Pasma
Rakocevic Sattler Schreiner Shaw
Stevens Stiles Tabuns Vanthof
Vaugeois West Wong-Tam  
Nays/contre (67)
Anand Bailey Barnes Bethlenfalvy
Bouma Bresee Byers Calandra
Cho (Scarborough North) Cho (Willowdale) Clark Coe
Crawford Cuzzetto Dixon Dowie
Dunlop Fedeli Flack Ford (York South—Weston)
Gallagher Murphy Ghamari Gill Grewal
Hardeman Harris Hogarth Holland
Jones (Chatham-Kent—Leamington) Jones (Dufferin—Caledon) Jordan Kanapathi
Kerzner Khanjin Kusendova-Bashta Leardi
Lecce Lumsden MacLeod Martin
McCarthy McGregor Mulroney Pang
Parsa Piccini Pierre Pirie
Quinn Rae Rickford Riddell
Sabawy Sandhu Sarrazin Saunderson
Skelly Smith (Peterborough—Kawartha) Smith (Scarborough Centre) Smith (Thornhill)
Surma Tangri Thompson Tibollo
Triantafilopoulos Wai Williams  

Second Reading of Bill 150, An Act to enact the Official Plan Adjustments Act, 2023 and to amend the Planning Act with respect to remedies.

Deuxième lecture du projet de loi 150, Loi édictant la Loi de 2023 sur les modifications apportées aux plans officiels et modifiant la Loi sur l'aménagement du territoire en ce qui concerne les recours.

Debate arose and after some time,

Il s’élève un débat et après quelque temps,

The question was then put.

La question a ensuite été mise aux voix.

Carried.

Adoptée.

Referred to the Standing Committee on Heritage, Infrastructure and Cultural Policy.

Renvoyé au Comité permanent du patrimoine, de l'infrastructure et de la culture.

At 8:51 p.m., pursuant to Standing Order 9(e), the Government House Leader indicated that no business would be called and therefore the House adjourned.

À 20 h 51, conformément à l’article 9 e) du Règlement, le leader parlementaire du gouvernement a indiqué qu’aucune autre affaire ne serait à l’ordre du jour et par conséquent, l’Assemblée a ajourné ses travaux.

Petitions Tabled Pursuant to Standing Order 42(a)

Pétitions déposées conformément à l'article 42 a) du règlement

No./ Petition title/Titre de la pétition Presented by/Présentée par
P-166 Child maltreatment Catherine Fife

Sessional Papers Presented Pursuant to Standing Order 43

Documents Parlementaires déposées conformément à l'article 43 du règlement

No., Suffix/Nº, Suffixe Title/Titre Date tabled/Date de dépôt
404 Cabinet Office, Board of Internal Economy Appointment - Member as Alternate Commissioner: Order in Council appointing the Honourable Andrea Khanjin by the Lieutenant Governor in Council from among the members of the Executive Council/Bureau du Conseil des ministres, Nomination à la Commission de régie interne - membre à titre de commissaire suppléante : Décret de la lieutenante-gouverneure en conseil nommant l'honorable Andrea Khanjin parmi les membres du Conseil exécutif November 17, 2023
405 Cabinet Office, Certificate pursuant to Standing Order 110(f)(1) re Intended Appointments: November 17, 2023 November 17, 2023
406 Cabinet Office, Order in Council 1685/2023 dated November 16, 2023 revoking the appointment of Anna Mae Gibbon as a Justice of the Peace/Bureau du Conseil des ministres, Décret 1685/2023, daté le 16 novembre 2023, révoquant la nomination du Anna Mae Gibbon comme juge de paix November 17, 2023
407 John Vanthof, Board of Internal Economy Appointment - Member as Alternate Commissioner: Letter from the House Leader of the Official Opposition informing that Terence Kernaghan, MPP, was appointed by the Caucus of the Official Opposition November 20, 2023

Responses To Written Questions

Réponses Aux Questions Écrites

No./ Submitted by/Présentée par Outcome/Résultat
126 Ted Hsu Final answer tabled November 20, 2023

Responses to Petitions

Réponses aux pétitions

No./ Petition title/Titre de la pétition Presented by/Présentée par Date tabled/Date de dépôt
P-53 Greenbelt expansion Peter Tabuns June 8, 2023
P-135 Millcroft golf course Effie J. Triantafilopoulos June 8, 2023