The committee met at 0901 in room 151.

BIG BAY RESORT
ASSOCIATION ACT, 2010

Consideration of Bill Pr38, An Act respecting Big Bay Resort Association.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): We’ll call the meeting to order. Since there is at least one new member today who wasn’t here last time, and potentially a second one if Mr. Murdoch appears, then—

Mr. Gerry Martiniuk: He will not.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): He will not. Okay, then we have one new member.

We are resuming clause-by-clause consideration of Bill Pr38, An Act respecting Big Bay Resort Association. When the committee adjourned on October 6, 2010, we completed the vote on form 2 of the bill, which is found on page 8. There are a number of votes that have to be taken. We started with the schedules because a lot of the other sections refer to the schedules. We did schedule 1. We did form 1. We were on form 2 and it was completed and carried, and then we were about to do form 3 when we ran out of time. Everybody remember? That’s where we’re at.

I will proceed at this point—Ms. DiNovo?

Ms. Cheri DiNovo: Yes, Mr. Chair. I would like to move a motion. I understand that there are other people here who would like to depute to this bill and represent another point of view. I wonder if they could be allowed to do so, if they’re willing to.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): We have a motion. I understand that this will require unanimous consent to proceed. Without getting into a long debate, is there unanimous consent to allow further deputations?

Mr. Lou Rinaldi: No.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): I heard a no. Then we will proceed as instructed.

We shall go to form 3. Is there any discussion on form 3? Seeing none, shall form 3 carry? Carried.

Form 4: Any discussion on form 4?

Ms. DiNovo, just for your edification, the forms are at the back of the bill. Form 4 is on the back.

Any discussion on form 4? Hearing none, shall form 4 carry? Carried.

We’re going to revert back to section 1. We’re going to go through the bill now section by section.

Mr. Gerry Martiniuk: Excuse me, Mr. Chair: Have we done the preamble?

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): No, the preamble comes after we’ve dealt with all the sections up to section 19. Then we go to the preamble, the title and the remainder.

We’re going to deal with the sections, starting with number 1. Any discussion on section 1? Shall section 1 carry? Carried.

Section 2: Any discussion on section 2? Hearing none, shall section 2 carry? Carried.

Any discussion on section 3? Hearing none, shall section 3 carry? Carried.

On section 4: Discussion on section 4? Hearing none, shall section 4 carry? Carried.

Ms. Cheri DiNovo: Mr. Chair, are these votes going to be recorded, or can I—

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): Someone has to request a recorded vote.

Ms. Cheri DiNovo: Could I request that these be recorded?

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): You want the balance of them recorded?

Ms. Cheri DiNovo: Yes. Had I known, I would have requested it at the top of the discussion, but definitely from here on in.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): From here on in. Okay, we have a request for recorded votes, so the balance shall be recorded.

Section 5: Is there any discussion on section 5? Seeing no discussion, all those in favour of section 5?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): Carried.

Section 6: Any discussion on section 6? Seeing no discussion, all those in favour?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): Carried.

Section 7: Any discussion on section 7? Seeing none, all those in favour?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): Carried.

On section 8: Is there any discussion on section 8? Seeing no discussion, all those in favour?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): Section 8 carries.

Section 9: Any discussion on section 9? Seeing no discussion, all those in favour?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

0910

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): Section 9 carries.

Section 10: Any discussion on section 10? Seeing no discussion, all those in favour?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): That carries.

Section 11: Any discussion on section 11? Seeing none, all those in favour?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): Section 11 carries.

Section 12: Any discussion on section 12? Seeing none, all those in favour?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): That carries.

Section 13: Any discussion? Seeing none, all those in favour?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): That carries.

Section 14: Any discussion? Seeing none, all those in favour?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): That carries.

Section 15: Any discussion? Seeing none, all those in favour?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): That carries.

Section 16: Any discussion? Seeing none, all those in favour?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): That carries.

Section 17: Any discussion? Seeing none, all those in favour?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): That carries.

Section 18: Any discussion? Seeing none, all those in favour?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): That carries.

Section 19: Any discussion? Seeing none, all those in favour?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): That carries.

We’ve dealt with the schedules and the forms, so we’ll go to the preamble. Shall the preamble carry?

Interjections: Carried.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): Sorry, I should have asked for discussion. I’ll go back; excuse me. Any discussion on the preamble? Ms. DiNovo.

Ms. Cheri DiNovo: Yes, just generally, as this is the last part that we’re voting on, I assume. The reason that we’re objecting is, first of all, the lack of voice for the residents and environmental concerns that have not been addressed adequately. Those are the general reasons. Again, I would ask for a recorded vote for this as with the other sections.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): Any other discussion? Okay, back to the preamble, again on a recorded vote. Shall the preamble carry?

Interjections: Carried.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): No, I said on a recorded vote. All those in favour?

The Clerk of the Committee (Mr. Katch Koch): Mr. Caplan, Mr. Leal, Mr. Rinaldi—

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): Mr. Ruprecht, you have to be in your seat.

Ms. Cheri DiNovo: Sorry, excuse me, Mr. Chair, are we voting on—this should be a recorded vote, or are we actually voting?

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): No, no. You’ve requested a recorded vote, so it is a recorded vote.

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): That carries.

The next one is the title. Any discussion on the title? No discussion on the title. All those in favour of the title?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): That carries.

The next item is asking if the bill should carry. Any discussion?

Mr. David Caplan: Carried.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): Okay, we still have a request for a recorded vote. All those in favour of the bill carrying?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): Carried.

Interjection.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): I don’t think—I guess we can. We have to do it, but I don’t think we can ask for a recorded vote. Well, I guess we can. Shall I report the bill to the House, again on a recorded vote?

Ayes

Caplan, Leal, Martiniuk, Rinaldi, Ruprecht.

Nays

DiNovo.

The Chair (Mr. Michael Prue): That carries.

That would be the conclusion of the bill.

The committee adjourned at 0914.

CONTENTS

Wednesday 20 October 2010

Big Bay Resort Association Act, 2010, Bill Pr38, Ms. Munro T-47

STANDING COMMITTEE ON REGULATIONS AND PRIVATE BILLS

Chair / Président

Mr. Michael Prue (Beaches–East York ND)

Vice-Chair / Vice-Président

Mr. Paul Miller (Hamilton East–Stoney Creek / Hamilton-Est–Stoney Creek ND)

Mr. David Caplan (Don Valley East / Don Valley-Est L)

Mr. Kim Craitor (Niagara Falls L)

Mr. Jeff Leal (Peterborough L)

Mr. Gerry Martiniuk (Cambridge PC)

Mr. Paul Miller (Hamilton East–Stoney Creek / Hamilton-Est–Stoney Creek ND)

Mr. Bill Murdoch (Bruce–Grey–Owen Sound PC)

Mr. Michael Prue (Beaches–East York ND)

Mr. Lou Rinaldi (Northumberland–Quinte West L)

Mr. Tony Ruprecht (Davenport L)

Substitutions / Membres remplaçants

Ms. Cheri DiNovo (Parkdale–High Park ND)

Clerk / Greffier

Mr. Katch Koch

Staff / Personnel

Ms. Susan Klein, legislative counsel